It is important to demonstrate whether the living conditions in Manchester in the first half of the nineteenth century were: bad; bad in some parameters and good in other parameters; or good. Or possibly the facts changed through the years.
Why is it important to have clarity in this question? Because we would be in a better position to answer the same question, with reference to the whole of Great Britain. It would be difficult to conceive of Manchester as being a horrible place, while the rest of Great Britain would be an advanced society. Equally, it would be difficult to conceive of Manchester as being a good society, while the rest of Great Britain would be poor, underfed, uneducated, and overworked. Or, as we have it in 1 Corinthians 14: ”And if Christ is not risen, then is our preaching vain, and your faith is also vain.”
If we have a definition as to what the living conditions were really like, then we can investigate questions of the next lower level:
- did the industrial system cause poverty in the towns?
- did the industrial system cause bad housing and sanitary conditions?
- did the industrial system cause extreme infant mortality?
- did the industrial system cause unnaturally low wages for the workers?
- did the industrial system cause unhappiness in the workers?
- did the industrial system cause frictions between classes of society?
Please note that these questions actually have two dimensions. For example, the first question divides into: a) was there poverty in the towns, worse than “before”? b) was this increased poverty due to the introduction of the industrial system?
With respect to the standards of living, there is little agreement between academic authors on food consumption, economic growth, wage growth, life expectancy / death rate. We can see this, inspecting the textual information in:
Wikipedia -> Industrial Revolution -> Social Effects -> Standards of Living
As to heights, there are four different calculations by three different academics, using official registers of heights of soldiers.
If the data and the descriptions in this paper, “Manchester, 1841 – 1851”, are accepted, then we can check other calculations which may exist: “Manchester, 1831 – 1841”, “Manchester, 1821 – 1831”, “Manchester, 1811 – 1821”, Manchester, 1801 – 1811”. OR, “Liverpool, 1841 – 1851”, “Leeds, 1841 – 1851”, “Birmingham, 1841 – 1851”, “Bradford, 1841 – 1851”.
Un comentario en “20.2. Introduction”